From the BlogSubscribe Now

Pepper Shrimp – The Taste of Middle Quarters in Hackensack NJ

I’ve been eating pepper shrimps (or ‘swimps,’ as some of us call it), since I was in high school and I can still remember my first time (it’s the same every time).

Biting into one of these Scotch-bonnet-infused on-the-go morsels, my tongue is instantly in flames, my eyes watering, heat passing from my throat and warming my stomach.

I involuntarily pull in air, slapping my tongue against my lips and the roof of my mouth, to try to cool it. That doesn’t work; nothing does. Now, even my lips are on fire.

I take a few seconds then, my mouth still reeling, I bite into another shrimp – head and all – continue the delicious torture, which, by now, is causing my nose to run.

Pepper Shrimps, crawfish really, typically come from the Black River, the longest in parish of St. Elizabeth, one of the longest in the island.

The shrimps are cooked in a mixture of Scotch bonnet and spices and sold in little paper or plastic bags of about 6 or so by roadside vendors in Middle Quarters, Jamaica’s “Shrimp Country.”

The shrimps are small, no more than an inch or an inch and half so we eat head and all. Some people peel them skin off, other people (I’m one) don’t.

Most visitors to Jamaica stay on the northwest for the spectacular beaches. But those who make it to the south coast usually discover an entirely different side the island, one that is rustic as well as charming.

Here, small cook shops abound and vendors sell typical Jamaican fare, using fresh ingredients grown locally in St. Elizabeth, the island’s “Bread Basket.”

On my way to visit a friend in New Jersey few weeks ago, I stopped at Mac West Indian Restaurant in Hackensack to get some escoveitch fish. While waiting, I noticed they had peppered shrimps and asked the server to add a couple packets to my bill.

I was surprised to see pepper shrimp on the menu at any of the restaurants I frequent. Seeing them brought back memories of some pepper shrimps I bought in the Bronx in the 80s.

I remember Michael driving us back to Manhattan where we were staying and the two of us eating shrimp after shrimp, our mouths ablaze because Ting, the carbonated grapefruit soft drink that someone at the restaurant had recommended, didn’t calm the fire in our mouths. (Apparently, milk is better but I hate milk.)

Michael was swearing like a sailor while I laughed and called him a wimp for not being able to handle “a little pepper.” I still smile at the memory.

Though they weren’t crawfish, the pepper shrimp I bought in Hackensack took me back to Middle Quarters. I could almost feel the sun on my face as I bit into my first one.

Pepper Shrimp
Write a review
  1. 4 cups water
  2. 1/2 cup chopped scallion
  3. 4 garlic cloves, crushed
  4. 3 fresh thyme sprigs
  5. 3 fresh Scotch bonnet or habanero chiles, halved and seeded
  6. 2 tablespoons salt
  7. 1/2 teaspoon black pepper
  8. 10 whole allspice
  9. 1 lb large shrimp
  1. Combine all ingredients except shrimp in a 4-quart heavy pot and bring to a boil, then reduce heat and simmer, covered, 20 minutes.
  2. Stir in shrimp, making sure they are just covered by liquid, and remove pot from heat. Cool shrimp in liquid to room temperature, uncovered, about 1 hour. Transfer shrimp with a slotted spoon to a plate or bowl and drizzle some of cooking liquid on top.


  1. Another recipe to save!!!! Thanks for this Marcia
    Marlys recently posted..Don’t Cry for Me, BordigheraMy Profile

  2. I love shrimp, and I love hot. I know that I wouldn’t be able to resist.
    Nancie ( recently posted..World Wide Photo Walk October 11, 2014My Profile

  3. yumm..shrimp ..i love it..and thanks for the recipe ..i will ask my mom to prepare it for me..
    manik recently posted..Top Diwali Facebook Covers photos 2014 free downloadMy Profile

  4. You had me at Scotch bonnet infused:)) I love all kinds of pepper. Would like to try this with crawfish; I’ve never eaten them.
    Lesley Peterson recently posted..Lucy the Elephant, America’s oldest roadside attractionMy Profile

  5. Yesterday I tried this recipe and guess what every one in my house where amassed, they said you are the one who never came in kitchen, how can you prepare this amazing stuff & sorry Marcia I didn’t took your name but publicly thanking you for yesterday’s gift of love from my family thanks a lot…
    Veronica Smith recently posted..Happy New Year Sagittarius 2015 Horoscope predictionMy Profile

  6. Delicious… thank you for the recipe, Marcia 🙂
    Muza-chan recently posted..Must see in Japan, authentic Japanese swordsMy Profile

  7. You’re quite welcome, Veronica. Glad you tried and liked it.

  8. Sounds delicious and very hot!!
    Leigh recently posted..5 Things to do in Mendoza, ArgentinaMy Profile