Though it seems simple enough, I’ve never made mannish water soup. I’ve never even tried to. Perhaps because it’s one of those Jamaican dishes that is best to cook outdoors over a wooden fire – sweat pouring down the face, arms and back, smoke stinging the eyes.
Or, perhaps as the name suggests, it should be prepared by men, which it is. Honestly, I don’t think I’ve ever heard of or seen a woman making mannish water soup. (Maybe with Jamaicans who live abroad, roles might have changed. Ditto the preparation. It’d be difficult to build a fire and cook outside.)
Considered an aphrodisiac, mannish water soup, is made from goat’s offal – the intestines, head, feet and testicles – which are scrupulously cleaned then washed (now, that I’ve seen women do), the head and feet roasted over an open fire then scraped to remove hair (I’ve seen boys no more than 10 do this part).
The meat is then cut into small pieces, mixed with green bananas, coco, yam, carrots, spinners (dumplings), seasoned with Scotch bonnet peppers, thyme, etc., and left to reduce to a delicious soup.
Mannish water soup gets its distinct flavor from the bananas with a light smoky taste from the goat.
Mannish water soup is served hot as an appetizer, in paper cups at large gatherings, like the weddings, parties. For less casual dining, like the event I attended this week, it is served in soup plates. You can even add white rum to kick the flavor up.
Admittedly, mannish water soup isn’t for everyone so I was surprised to see a recipe on the Food Network, even more surprised that it suggested that lamb could be substituted. Wonder what the purists would think.
So is mannish water soup an aphrodiasic? Well…it probably depends on how much you end up drinking.
- 4 lb. goat’s head, tripe and feet (get butcher to cut in small pieces)
- 12 green bananas
- 1 lb. flour for spinners
- 3-4 hot peppers
- 1 lb. coco
- ½ lb. carrots
- ½ lb turnips
- 3 chochos
- 3 gallons water
- ½ lb scallion
- 4 sprigs thyme
- 2 lb. yam
- Salt to taste
- Chop meat into small pieces (if not already chopped)
- Wash and place in a 5-gallon container with 3 gallons of hot water.
- When the water returns to a boil, simmer until meat is cooked soft (about 2 ½ -3 hours).
- Peel green bananas and add all other ingredients, except for flour, i.e. vegetables, seasonings etc. cook uncovered for one hour more.
- Use flour to make spinners. Add to stock.
- Correct seasoning and remove hot peppers. Add more water if necessary.
- Serve hot.
Have a foodie post you’d like to share? Join the #FoodieTuesday linkup and add it here –
- Add the link to your foodie post in the link tool below.
- As a courtesy, please include a link back to this post.
- To make it a fun linkup, don’t forget to leave a comment here and comment on as many posts as you can.
- If you Tweet, G+, Facebook please use the hashtag #FoodieTuesday.
14 comments on “Mannish Water Soup, An Aphrodiasic?”
Marcia, I usually love the sound of the dishes you post, but this one really doesn’t appeal I’m sorry to say! From the name to the ingredients, I really don’t think I could stomach it. I’m usually an adventurous eater but it’s the offal and testicles that get me. Interesting to read about though!!!
I’ve never been a fan of goat meat, but I would be willing to try this. 🙂
I have to admit, the contents of this soup don’t appeal to me, but I find it interesting that such a combination would be considered an aphrodisiac! Thanks for the Tuesday link up!
Hi Marcia. Looks like a very hearty soup that would be nice in the winter time. Goat’s offal makes me a little queasy. I think I would go with the lamb. This might make a nice crockpot dish.
Jave SWEARS by mannish water. I’ve never tried it although your picture of it looks good. He also swears by his blended drinks like octopus, peanuts, Guinness – it’s all a bit too much for me! Lol!
Thank you for the recipe, Marcia 🙂
Always amazes me the different foods that are considered aphrodisiacs! Oysters are a popular one here in the states, but for me champagne works just fine!;-)
You’re welcome, Lili!
Hahaha, doesn’t surprise me, Dana. He’s a man.
I’ve never even heard of that concoction – they’re always making up new ones.
Believe me, I understand, Nancie.
Honestly, I think if I thought about it, I wouldn’t eat it either. Probably easier said than done though.
Not sure where the idea of it being an aphrodisiac came from….it’s very likely only in the mind.
Cool, Sonja! You’re a good sport.
I agree, Phoebe. This one isn’t for everyone at all.
It probably ranks right up there with some of the other weird foods from around the world.
I agree, Jess. Champagne, eh? Blame the bubbles.
Comments are closed.